Welcome to the Procrustes Effect, where your creativity either stretches to breaking point or gets hacked down to size. It’s the tragic folklore of Procrustes, the sadistic host who made every traveler fit his bed, either by the rack or the blade. 

You see, the Procrustes Effect isn’t just some ancient Greek horror story. It's the ghost that haunts every brainstorming session, every blank page, every whiteboard filled with potential. It's the slick corporate catchphrase that drowns out your authentic voice. It’s that little voice whispering, “Color inside the lines,” “Play it safe,” “Don’t rock the boat.”

Imagine Van Gogh painting by numbers. Picture Kafka filling out a spreadsheet. Feel that itch? That's the Procrustes Effect gnawing at your soul, daring you to be ordinary. It's the daily grind that turns your vibrant ideas into beige shadows, the tyranny of ‘good enough’ that shackles the extraordinary. 

In the world of creativity, the Procrustes Effect is the enemy of innovation, the saboteur of originality. It's the death of art by a thousand cuts, each one shaving off a piece of your unique vision until all that's left is a homogenized husk, a corporate-friendly, focus-group-approved abomination.

The Why

The Procrustes Effect can be detrimental to the creative process. Like strapping a thoroughbred to a cart horse. It's the ghost that haunts creatives, whispering in their ears, "play it safe, stick to the rules." But true creatives? They shatter norms, trample traditions. They’re the ones unafraid to take a jackhammer to the status quo.

For example, consider a graphic designer who's been asked to cook up a new logo. Now she could play safe, stick to the beaten path, draw something that fits the corporate mold, but where's the fun in that? She can instead dive into the wild, explore the outlandish, the bizarre. And you know what she'd get? A masterpiece, a memorable image that’ll burn into people's minds.

The How

The Procrustes Effect can be a major obstacle, limiting your ability to fully express yourself and realize your vision. Here's how to avoid it:

  1. Recognize the limitations of pre-existing rules and conventions. They’re not etched in stone, they're not the Ten Commandments.
  2. Learn which rules to bend and which rules to break. It’s the art of choosing your battles wisely.
  3. Embrace experimentation and exploration in the creative process. Creativity thrives in the unknown, in the unexplored, so don't play it safe.
  4. Focus on the core message or idea behind the creative work, rather than trying to fit it into a pre-existing mold. Don’t get lost in the details, in the rules, in the noise.
  5. Seek feedback and input from others to get new perspectives and ideas. It’s like a breath of fresh air for your creativity.
  6. Avoid being too attached to a single idea or concept, and be willing to pivot if necessary. If an idea isn't working, don’t dig your heels in. Pivot, improvise, adapt.

Remember, breaking rules for the heck of it isn’t smart either. It's like setting your house on fire to kill a spider. Balance is the name of the game. Understand the rules but don't let them rule you. Learn to waltz on the tightrope between tradition and innovation. Do that, and Procrustes won’t stand a chance.

Mistakes to Avoid

Now, imagine yourself in a minefield, your creativity the ticking bomb underfoot. You’re on this treacherous journey to innovation, but there are pitfalls you need to sidestep or risk detonation:

  • Ignoring the basics. It's like diving without knowing how to swim. You can fight against the norms all you want, but if you don’t know your craft inside out, your rebellion is just noise. The basics, they're the bones, the structure. Sure, dress it up, break some rules, but remember, no bones, no body.
  • Breaking rules for the sake of breaking them. That's not creativity; that's chaos. Rules are there for a reason. Bend them, break them, but only if it serves your big picture, your vision. Rule-breaking is a tool, not a goal.
  • Failing to consider the audience. It’s one thing to challenge conventions, quite another to alienate your audience with something so outlandish they can’t wrap their heads around it. No one enjoys a puzzle without a solution.
  • Refusing to collaborate. If you're going solo all the time, it's like driving with your eyes closed. You’re missing out on the road signs, the scenery, the different perspectives. Collaboration is not your enemy; it's your co-pilot, your guide.
  • Being too attached to a single idea or concept. It’s a creativity killer, a straightjacket. Got a brilliant idea? Great. But if it doesn't work, don’t dig your heels in. Be nimble, be flexible. Drop it, pick up another, move on.

Remember, your creativity is a wild, rebellious beast. But don’t let it run riot. Guide it, nurture it, give it a direction. Avoid the pitfalls and you might just blow minds, not step on the bombs.

Mental Models for Overcoming the Procrustes Effect

Now, let's talk about escape routes, mind-tricks to break out of Procrustes' bed. There are a few mental toolkits you can use to stick it to the Procrustes Effect:

  • The Contrarian Approach: Yeah, it sounds like that grumpy old dude who argues for the sake of it, but it's not. This is about going against the flow, rebelling against the norm. It's about standing on the rooftops and screaming, "What if?" at the top of your lungs. It's about sparking innovation by challenging the status quo.
  • The Divergent Thinking Model: This isn't some sequel to a teen novel. It's about an idea explosion, a brainstorming tsunami. It's about creating a shower of ideas, however wild or absurd they might be. Remember, an oyster needs a bit of grit to make a pearl.
  • The Abstraction Ladder: It's not a literal ladder, more like a mental game of Jenga. It's about peeling back the layers of complexity, like an onion, till you’re left with the bare, abstract core. It's your microscope to see new ideas in the simplest of things.
  • First Principles Thinking: This is like the Big Bang of an idea. It's about breaking down complex problems into atomic elements, the fundamental truths. Once you strip it down to the bones, you can rearrange, rebuild, reimagine.
  • The Analogical Thinking Model: It’s your mental thesaurus. It's about drawing parallels, making connections where none existed. It's about using analogies, metaphors to light your path to innovation.

Think of these models as your toolbox. They're your Houdini tricks to escape the iron bed of Procrustes. Play around with them, mix them, use them to shatter the shackles of the norm. Do that, and you won't just survive the Procrustes Effect. You'll conquer it.


The Procrustes Effect is the silent creativity strangler. It lures you in with the safety of the known, the comfort of the norms, the fear of being different. It's like quicksand for creatives, the more you struggle to fit in, the deeper you sink.

But, here's the twist, the rebel yell: recognize the chains, see them for what they are – limitations. Step off the beaten path. Dive into the ocean of possibilities, swim against the tide of conformity. It's not about breaking the rules just because; it's about hunting for that kernel of uniqueness, the core idea that's begging to be unleashed.

Table of Contents
Great! Next, complete checkout for full access to The Mental Models Club.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to The Mental Models Club.
Success! Your account is fully activated, you now have access to all content.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.